TVNewser Show TVNewser TVSpy SocialTimes AllFacebook GalleyCat PRNewser AgencySpy FishbowlNY FishbowlDC MediaJobsDaily UnBeige 10,000 Words

CBS cancels first Twitter show, $#*! My Dad Says

The first network TV show based on a Twitter account has been cut due to struggling ratings. CBS has canceled $#*! My Dad Says, the comedy based on Justin Halpern’s popular Twitter account @shitmydadsays.

“The cancellation of $#*! is a win for creativity,” argues TV.com’s Tim Surette. “CBS was eager to cash in on the Twitter feed, but never quite found a groove for the show other than ‘William Shatner plays a cranky man.’ Hopefully the show’s failure will keep others from trying to make shows based on blogs, Twitter feeds, tumblr pages, match.com profiles, email addresses, and Friendster pages.”

I have the opposite perspective: why wouldn’t programmers tap the endless creativity of millions of self-publishers on the web? The crowd is always more creative, and Twitter and Tumblr and other micro-publishing platforms are a great source of ideas. The key is to expand the show beyond its online genesis to make compelling, sustainable television.

Meanwhile, we haven’t heard any updates on three other Twitter-based shows CBS is exploring. What do you think? Is basing shows on Twitter overkill? Or great source of ideas?

Mediabistro Event

TVNewser Show Coming to NYC on April 29!

TVNewser ShowThe TVNewser Show Seminar & Media Job Fair will explore the way TV business and technologies are changing through informative panels and discussions with industry experts. Attendees will also have the opportunity to network with other like-minded professionals at the event's exclusive media job fair. Register before midnight on April 28 to save on on-site pricing!